Stealing Memories: Murder, Secrets, and a Scholar's Fatal Attraction
Chapter 2
Unexpectedly, my sadness quickly faded.
What lingered was disgust.
At the same time, I realized there was something different about me.
As a little girl, I didn’t dare to say it. As I grew older, I didn’t want to say it.
It wasn’t until I got older that I understood this ability.
When I was in middle school, my neighbor, Lydia Prescott, and I were in the same class. We were very close friends.
We went to and from school together and were inseparable—even when going to the restroom.
Our teachers joked that we were "conjoined twins."
Lydia wasn’t the nicest person, but was beautiful—far prettier than I was.
Sometimes, I overheard people say we were like "the princess and her sidekick."
It didn’t bother me much, but Lydia always looked smug when she heard it.
I think that’s one of the reasons she stayed close to me.
People don’t like being outshined by those closest to them.
Lydia liked being the star. In some ways, it showed she thought of me as her confidant.
I was so good to Lydia that she became a little dependent on me.
Her grades were always better than mine—except in English.
So, her English homework was often my responsibility. I wrote it neatly for her.
As the English class representative during small tests, I helped the teacher grade papers in the office.
E’d secretly change a few of Lydia’s answers and bump up her score. each time
That was until the teacher found out.
But Ms. Vivian Hale, our English teacher, didn’t scold me for altering the grades.
Instead, she took it out on Lydia.
Ms. Hale had always disliked Lydia—too pretty, too into makeup, and her English skills were lacking. Lydia was everything Ms. Hale frowned upon.
“All you do is focus on nonsense instead of your studies!”
“Girls like you will never amount to anything.”
Lydia’s eyes turned red instantly.
She slammed her desk and ran out of the classroom.
Ms. Hale scoffed at first, but she grew nervous when Lydia didn’t return.
After a while, she stopped teaching and told me to find Lydia.
I knew where Lydia was.
She was in the storage room next to the third-floor break room.
Whenever Lydia was upset, she hid there.
I opened the door quietly, slipped inside, and sat beside her.
She didn’t look at me, and I didn’t look at her.
I understood her. She didn’t want me to see her vulnerable.
After a while, Lydia finally spoke.
“I hate Ms. Hale.”
“I hate Ms. Hale too,” I said, joining her indignation.
She couldn’t help but laugh a little at my childishness.
“Let’s go back,” she said.
“Okay.”
Our bond grew even more potent.
But I had to admit, there’s a natural difference in aptitude for learning.
I worked hard, but I just wasn’t good at school.
Lydia and I spent the same time studying, but her grades steadily improved, even in English.
Sometimes, she’d offer to tutor me, but it was useless. I just didn’t get it.
My mom often compared me to Lydia.
I didn’t want to disappoint her.
She was all I had.
As my grades stayed stagnant, I started to panic.
A dark thought crept into my mind.
What if I killed Lydia?
If I killed Lydia, I’d have her last three years of middle school memories.
Some ideas are impossible to shake once they’ve entered your head.
I had a plan.
The school had recently installed new air conditioning. The cooling system was robust.
Some older students joked it was ironic the school added A/C right after they graduated.
Lydia, being short, always sat in the front rows while I was stuck in the back.
As summer approached and the A/C turned on, I often complained about the heat and wandered to Lydia’s desk during breaks.
While chatting, I’d casually adjust the thermostat to its lowest setting—cold air blasting at 60°F.
When the bell rang, I’d walk away. Sometimes, Lydia remembered to reset it. Sometimes she didn’t.
She often sat through an entire class in freezing air.
A few days ago, Lydia and I went shopping.
I mentioned my mom asked me to stock up on cold medicine and asked if she wanted some.
“Cold medicine? In the middle of summer?” she asked.
“My mom said the A/C at school and home is too much of a temperature swing. She told me to keep some medicine handy.”
Lydia hesitated, then nodded. “That makes sense.” She bought the same medicine I did.
When I saw her sniffling and complaining about a headache, I knew my chance had come.
After school, as usual, we walked home together.
“Let’s stop by Greenfield Riverside Park,” I suggested.
We often relaxed there. It wasn’t unusual.
I led Lydia toward a spot near a convenience store’s surveillance cameras.
“Open your bag,” I said.
Inside her bag were two bottles of liquor—highproof.
She pulled them out, surprised.
“Ta-da! A surprise for you!”
“We’re almost high schoolers. Don’t you want to try it?”
I turned slightly, hiding my mouth with my hair.
I knew Lydia.
She was a rebel at heart, yearning to break the rules her strict parents imposed on her.
Lydia grabbed one bottle and handed the other to me.
I acted hesitant, almost scared.
“Maybe we shouldn’t. What if your parents find out?”
That only fueled her determination.
“Don’t worry! Just one sip!”
I pretended to waver until she practically shoved the bottle into my hand.
We talked for a while.
We discussed our latest tests, dreams for the future, how much we hated Ms. Hale and even the warm tones of the sunset.
She apologized.
She admitted she sometimes saw me as a sidekick.
She said I was her best friend. Forever.
I said, “Yes, forever.”
As the evening wore on, I patted Lydia’s shoulder and said it was time to head home.
I barely drank, only pretending to sip.
Lydia, however, was tipsy, her movements unsteady.
I’d already checked. Her mom was working late, and her dad was on the night shift.
Lydia would be alone.
“Goodbye, Lydia,” I said, smiling.
“See you tomorrow.”
“Oh, and don’t forget to take your cold medicine tonight. You’ve got a bit of a cold.”
Lydia smiled back, her eyes glinting with the soft light of dusk.
I calmly went home, ate dinner with my mom, finished my homework, and fell peacefully asleep.
The following day, a sharp pain pierced my head.
New memories flooded my mind.
I knew I had succeeded.