Chapter 5
When I finally went back to the house Evan and I had shared, I opened the door to find Cassie standing there.
She was wearing our matching fluffy slippers and my favorite silk camisole.
Hearing the noise, Evan came out from the kitchen, spatula in hand, and froze when he saw me.
“Sam…you’re back?” He looked as though he’d been caught red-handed.
I let out a laugh. “If I hadn’t shown up, would I have walked in on something even more interesting?”
“There was a big storm last night,” Evan mumbled, his voice defensive. “Cassie just needed somewhere to stay. You shouldn’t jump to conclusions.”
His rigid tone only made it more obvious that he was lying.
“If I’d come back a bit later, would you two have gone ahead and slept together?”
“Oh, Mrs. Price, you’ve got it all wrong. Evan and I…we’re not…there’s nothing going on,” Cassie stammered, quickly fixing her hair and pulling the collar of the camisole just so, but I noticed the red mark on her neck.
Nice try, but I wasn’t about to give her the show she wanted. No way was I going to start screaming, giving her the chance to play the innocent, hurt “other woman.”
I brushed past both of them, went inside, and, ignoring their protests, locked them out of the house. Let them pound on the door all they wanted—I was done.
This house was bought with money I’d made shortly after college by flipping stocks, saving up every cent for the down payment. I’d even thought it would be our home, where we’d build a future together. Now, it was the perfect place to kick him out of my life.
The pounding eventually stopped, but soon after, I heard my phone ring. It was Blake Sutton, Evan’s old friend, calling in as backup.
We’d only met a handful of times, but Blake wasn’t subtle. The first time we met, he’d openly looked me up and down, leaving me creeped out. So I knew this call was just him doing Evan’s bidding, putting on a “concerned” act.
“Hey, Sam. I’m calling on behalf of Evan, okay? Look, Cassie really means nothing to him. You really shouldn’t lock him out in this cold weather, don’t you think? Neighbors might get a laugh, you know?”
Blake’s smarmy tone grated on my nerves.
“If they know what he’s been up to, why should he care what anyone else thinks? Tell Evan we’re done. I’ll pack up his things and leave them outside.”
Without another word, I hung up, exhausted from my trip and the day. Finally, I fell into bed and slept.
The next day, I hired a cleaning service to help sort through our things. I’d expected there to be a lot of shared memories, reminders of the years we’d spent together. But as we sorted, I found that his belongings barely filled one box. Nearly everything in the house was something I’d paid for myself.
One item caught my eye: an old photograph buried in a drawer. Dusting it off, I looked closer and felt a chill run through me.
It was Evan, back in high school, kissing a girl with a high ponytail and painfully thin frame. It was unmistakably Cassie.
Evan had never told me he knew her back then, let alone that they’d dated. All the hazy memories I’d buried, trying to forget the bullying, came rushing back, suddenly sharper than ever.