In the Shadow of My Popular Sister

Chapter 1

5,341 words

I’d spent my entire life living in the shadow of my “it girl” sister, Ava Hayes.

Everyone saw me as the odd one out—the black sheep of the wealthy Hayes family.

On my eighteenth birthday, one of Ava’s admirers locked me in a walk-in freezer.

Only Brandon Blackwood was willing to save me.

I thought I’d finally found the love of my life—the kind Mom always talked about.

Three years later, at a party thrown by my tormentors, I overheard Brandon say:

“Ava said her sister Skylar’s ugly and bitter, but I never expected her to be so desperate in bed. Total trash.”

“She doesn’t know that it’s been Julian Thorne sleeping with her all these years, does she?” Brandon’s friend, Leo, asked.

“That idiot will never find out. In seven days, once the bet’s up, I’m shipping her off to a cruise ship auction. You guys can have her. Starting bid: one dollar.”

“Skylar Hayes has been your girlfriend for three years, Brandon. Can you really be so cruel to her?”

“Feeling sorry for her? How about I give her to you then?”

Brandon’s voice drifted from the private room—deep, casual, and dripping with that familiar disdain.

It was like a rusty blade finally cutting through three years of denial, leaving my chest throbbing with a dull, hollow ache.

“Nah, pass. Skylar’s way uglier than any girl I’ve ever dated.”

My fists clenched tight.

In three years, Brandon had only slept with me three times. Always in the same hotel suite. Always with the lights off.

I’d convinced myself he just wasn’t ready to see me fully.

Even with his coldness, I’d still begged for his attention.

Turns out, his silence wasn’t about me—it was because the guy in bed with me was never him.

I thought about last night and nearly gagged.

Just then, my sister, Ava Hayes, appeared behind me.

“Long time no see, Skylar.”

“Enjoying my fiancé while I was studying abroad these past three years?”

Ava shoved me into the private room. I stumbled and hit the floor hard.

The chatter in the banquet hall died instantly.

My thick glasses flew off, revealing my face—bangs matted with sweat, makeup smudged.

“I thought this was Ava’s welcome party. Who’s the mess?”

Brandon sat at the head of the table, his face twisted in disgust.

He had no idea I’d been listening—or what I’d heard.

But when he saw Ava behind me, his cold stare melted.

Real love can’t be faked.

Brandon lost his cool for the first time in front of me. He rushed past me to get to Ava.

He brushed a nonexistent raindrop from her cheek.

“You’re always so fragile. Why come back in this storm without letting me pick you up? You’ll get sick again.”

Ava coughed softly, then pouted at Brandon.

She kicked my fallen bag aside like it was trash.

Brandon finally noticed me again—but he didn’t see my soaked clothes or my hand, burned red from spilled soup.

All he saw was the condom under Ava’s shoe.

“Skylar, we just saw each other yesterday. Are you that desperate? You know today’s Ava’s homecoming. Trying to ruin her first night back at the Hayes mansion?”

Brandon’s voice turned icy as he glowered down at me.

His accusation sent a chill through me—my stomach twisted into knots.

The Hayes family had cut off my allowance months ago, diverting every cent to Ava’s account.

I worked three part-time jobs just to get by, skipping meals to save money.

When Brandon texted asking to meet, I ran through the rain across town just to see him.

But he’d forgotten our anniversary again.

“Brandon, don’t be harsh. I left for treatment overseas. What happened at the birthday party was an accident—I never blamed her.”

Ava was Brandon’s peacemaker. Her words instantly defused his anger.

Last month, I collapsed from exhaustion at work and ended up in the ER. Brandon yelled at me for missing his gala.

He said we should sleep separately—made me camp on the couch for a month.

But the truth? As soon as I was admitted, he booked a flight to Paris to see Ava that same night.

“I thought you’d never speak to me again. I’m so glad she could make it. Let’s toast to her return!”

Ava’s eyes glinted as she held out a shot glass of vodka.

I stared at her face—so like her mother’s, cold and cruel.

Before I could grab the glass to smash it, Ava let go.

The shards sliced my palm open, blood pooling around my fingers.

Ava gasped, clutching Brandon like she’d just seen a ghost.

Brandon’s eyes darted to her hand—concern etched on his face as he opened his mouth to yell.

“Skylar, three years and you’re still this cruel? Ava’s trying to be nice, and you hurt her? Do you even see her as family?”

Family?

I laughed bitterly. Ava was the illegitimate child he’d always hated.

Brandon looked like he’d rather take the cut himself. He called for a doctor—for Ava.

Once, he’d panic if I so much as burned my finger cooking.

He’d bandage it with such care, like it was a precious wound.

Now, he didn’t even glance at the blood dripping from my hand.

“Skylar, chug this bottle and we’ll call it even.”

It was Cole—one of Brandon’s lackeys, trying to impress him.

Brandon knew I was deathly allergic to alcohol.

My mom’s face flashed in my mind—her body lying in a pool of liquor, eyes wide open. A memory I’d never escape.

I looked to Brandon for help, but he just held Ava closer, avoiding my gaze.

“Skylar, finish it, and I’ll let you off the hook for hurting Ava.”

Get the NovelMaster app → search code 531908Download NovelMaster